Alpha vs. Outcomes: Why Returns Don’t Matter (As Much As You Think)
Spend any time around investment professionals and you’ll hear the same goal again and again: “generate alpha.” But is beating the market really the point?
What is alpha, anyway?
In investing, alpha is the amount by which a portfolio outperforms its benchmark. If your benchmark returns 8% and your portfolio returns 10%, that 2% difference is your alpha.
For many in the industry, finding alpha is the end-all, be-all of investing.
My response? Poppycock!
Don’t get me wrong. I will always look for opportunities to capture alpha. But alpha is not my primary focus. Here are three reasons why a single-minded focus on alpha misses the mark:
- Investment management vs. financial planning
- Benchmarks and historical performance
- Outcomes vs. alpha
Reason #1: Investing is only one piece of the puzzle
Notice who’s chasing alpha: investment professionals. As a rule, they focus only on investments. That means goals, cash flow, taxes, insurance, estate planning, college planning, charitable giving, and much more can get left out.
A financial planner looks at all of those pieces, and your investments. When your whole financial life is on the table, a narrow focus on beating the market simply isn’t the wisest choice.
Question #1: Do you (or your advisor) take a holistic approach to your financial plan, or are you being lured in by the siren song of alpha?
Reason #2: Alpha rarely lasts
The research is clear, and it’s been clear for decades. S&P’s SPIVA scorecards consistently show that most actively managed funds fail to beat their benchmarks over the long run. And Dalbar’s investor behavior studies show that the average investor often earns far less than the funds they own, largely by chasing performance.
Some managers will claim to deliver alpha by comparing their results to an index. Often, though, it’s the wrong index. Their strategy is really tracking a different benchmark altogether.
To be clear, I’m a huge believer in factor-based investing. Factors like market, size, value, and profitability have been shown to be both present and persistent over time. But there’s a big difference between pursuing a factor that’s backed by evidence and simply trying to outguess an index.
Question #2: Do you (or your advisor) have an Investment Policy Statement (IPS) with an appropriate benchmark for measuring performance?
Reason #3: Outcomes matter most
This is the big one. Investments are only a tool to support a comprehensive financial plan. And every good plan is built around the outcomes you want.
The order matters:
- Decide where you want to go (your outcomes)
- Map the path (your plan)
- Choose the tools to get you there (investments being just one of them)
Too many people focus only on investment performance and lose sight of the outcomes.
I recently met with a seasoned investor who had a solid, well-monitored portfolio. It was a bit overly complex for my taste, but clearly well thought out. What struck me was that he hadn’t fully realized how many doors his investing success had opened for his future. I encouraged him to think about what truly matters to him and his spouse, and whether they’re positioned to pursue it. I’m confident he’ll take that question to heart.
Question #3: Have you (or your advisor) identified the outcomes that matter most to you and your family, and put a plan in place to give them the best chance of happening?
Life isn’t about the numbers
I’m as big a numbers geek as the next person. Honestly, my job would be so much easier if all I had to think about was investments and alpha.
But life isn’t about numbers. It’s about making an impact on others, something I’ve come to call significance.
One last, personal thought: there is one Alpha that’s absolutely worth pursuing. I’ll let you think on that one, and feel free to reach out if you’d like to talk about it.
I hope this post gives you a little extra motivation to dig into your own plan and ask whether you’re on track for the outcomes that matter most.
Ready to focus on what really matters? Reach out to our team to start the conversation.
This content is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.




