All blogs

Disability Insurance: Understanding the Basics

First published on
August 11, 2023
Updated on
August 11, 2023

Ever wonder if you need disability insurance? In this article, financial advisor Bob Anderberg provides an overview of the basics of disability insurance.

Curt Stowers, CFP®, PhD, MS
Curt Stowers, CFP®, PhD, MS
President & Financial Advisor

What’s your most valuable financial asset? It isn’t your house or your retirement account. It’s your ability to earn a paycheck.

Most of us think about life insurance, which protects our family if we’re no longer here. But what if an illness or injury keeps you from working, and life goes on? The bills keep coming, but the paycheck stops.

That scenario is more common than many people realize. According to the Social Security Administration, about 1 in 4 of today’s 20-year-olds will become disabled before reaching retirement age.

Why Social Security alone isn’t enough

Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) exists, but it’s a thin safety net:

  • Strict definition: You must be unable to do any substantial work, and your condition must be expected to last at least a year.
  • Modest benefits: The average SSDI payment for a disabled worker is about $1,630 a month in 2026.
  • Long waits: There’s a five-month waiting period, and approval can take much longer.

That’s where disability insurance comes in. Here are the basics you need to know.

‍

1. Know how your policy defines “disabled”

This is the single most important detail in any disability policy. There are three main definitions:

Definition How it works Cost
Own Occupation Pays if you can’t do the duties of your specific job, even if you could work in another field Highest
Any Occupation Pays only if you can’t do any job suited to your education, training, or experience Lowest
Split Definition Common in group plans. Starts as own occupation (often for two years), then switches to any occupation In between

See the difference: the surgeon example

Imagine a surgeon who develops a hand tremor and can no longer operate, but is otherwise healthy.

  • Own Occupation: The policy pays. The surgeon can’t perform surgery, so they qualify, even if they could work in another role.
  • Any Occupation: The policy likely doesn’t pay. The surgeon would be expected to work in a related role, such as a non-surgical physician, even at lower pay.
  • Split Definition: The policy pays for the first two years while the surgeon retrains. After that, benefits continue only if they can’t do any suitable job.

Now imagine that same surgeon suffers a head injury that causes memory loss. In that case, they’d likely qualify under all three definitions.

The takeaway: The more specialized (and well-paid) your career, the more valuable Own Occupation coverage becomes.

‍

2. Understand the key features

The elimination period

This is how long you must be disabled before benefits begin. Think of it as a deductible measured in time. 90 days is common.

The longer the elimination period, the lower your premium. Just make sure you have an emergency fund or short-term disability coverage to bridge the gap.

How much the policy pays

Aim for coverage that replaces about 60–70% of your income. That may sound low, but if your benefits are tax-free (more on that below), it can go further than you’d think.

The Social Security offset

Many group policies reduce your benefit by any Social Security disability you receive.

Example: Your group policy promises $3,000 a month. You’re approved for $2,000 a month from Social Security. With an offset, your policy pays only $1,000. Your total is still $3,000, not $5,000.

It’s worth checking whether your policy includes an offset before you count on the full benefit.

‍

3. Know where to get coverage

Disability insurance comes from two main sources: group plans through your employer, and individual policies you buy on your own. Many people use both, adding an individual policy to fill gaps in their group coverage.

Feature Group (employer) Individual (private)
Cost Low or free Higher, but you control the terms
Portability Usually ends when you leave the job Goes with you from job to job
Social Security offset Common Typically none, so you may collect both
Taxes on benefits Taxable if your employer paid the premium Tax-free if you paid the premium with after-tax dollars

‍

A closer look at taxes

Who pays the premium decides whether your benefits are taxed:

  • You pay with after-tax dollars: Benefits are tax-free, so you need less coverage to replace the same take-home pay.
  • Your employer pays: Benefits are taxable income.
  • You split the cost: Benefits are taxed in proportion. If your employer pays 70% of the premium and you pay 30%, about 70% of your benefit is taxable.

A few more things to check

  • Supplemental group coverage: If your employer lets you buy extra coverage, ask whether you can keep it if you leave.
  • Career changes: With an individual policy, moving into a more hazardous profession may raise your premium or limit your coverage.

5 questions to ask about your coverage

  1. How does my policy define “disabled”: own occupation, any occupation, or split?
  2. How long is the elimination period, and can my emergency fund cover it?
  3. What percentage of my income will it replace, after taxes?
  4. Will my benefit be reduced by Social Security disability?
  5. Can I keep this coverage if I change jobs?

‍

The bottom line

A disability can affect your family’s finances both now (like helping the kids through college) and far into the future (like your retirement). The right coverage protects the one asset that makes every other goal possible: your income.

A financial planner can help you figure out how much coverage you need, and which type, so your plan stays on track no matter what happens.

Not sure if you’re covered? Schedule a free consultation and we’ll help you review your options.

Got questions?

Apply for a free Financial Health Cycle Snapshot call with our team to get all your questions answered.

Book a Call

Join Our Mailing List

Learn how to build a life of freedom and significance with the right financial habits

By clicking Join Mailing List you're confirming that you agree with our Privacy Policy

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.